Project Brief Template: Get Comparable Proposals from QA and Testing Companies

Edited by QA Directory Research Team · Evidence checked: · How the ranking works

Why a shared brief makes proposals comparable

Three to five shortlisted Python QA companies will answer the same questions only if you ask them the same questions. A written brief removes the guesswork: each bidder prices the same scope, plans for the same team shape and commits to the same working practices. When the replies arrive, you compare like with like instead of comparing how well each company guessed what you wanted.

How to use this template

  1. Copy the sections below into a document you own and delete any row that does not apply to your project.
  2. Fill in the buyer-side fields — context, goals, environment, budget range — before anyone sees the brief. Leave the budget field blank only if you genuinely have no range, and say so.
  3. Send the identical document to every shortlisted company on the same day, with the same deadline.
  4. If one bidder raises a clarifying question, circulate both the question and your answer to all of them.
  5. Ask each bidder to return the brief with its answers in the same section order, so nothing is buried in prose.
  6. Score the replies against the criteria table near the end of this page before you discuss price in detail.

The brief template

1. Company and product context

Field What to write Example
Your organisation Sector, size band, where the engineering team sits “B2B logistics platform; engineering team split across two countries”
Product What the Python application does and who uses it “Internal scheduling service used by warehouse staff”
Current QA state What testing exists today and who runs it “Some pytest unit tests; no automated end-to-end coverage; manual regression before releases”
Why now The trigger for this engagement “Release cadence is increasing and manual regression is the bottleneck”

2. Scope and goals

Field What to write Example
In scope The testing work you are buying, named by type “API test automation, end-to-end browser tests, a CI release gate”
Out of scope Work bidders should not price “Load testing of third-party payment providers”
Success criteria Observable outcomes, not effort “A regression suite that runs on every pull request and reports pass/fail”
Deliverables Artefacts you expect to own at the end “Test code in our repository, a short runbook, a handover session”

3. Engagement model

Field What to write Example
Preferred model Staff augmentation, a dedicated team, or a fixed-scope project “Dedicated team of test engineers working alongside our developers”
Alternative models Whether you will consider another shape “A fixed-scope phase followed by an ongoing retainer is acceptable”
Duration Expected length and any review points “Initial phase, then a review before any extension”
Your involvement How much product and engineering time you can give “A product owner available for refinement; developers available for pairing”

4. Team and roles

Field What to write Example
Roles needed Each role and what it does on your project “Test automation engineer; QA lead for test strategy”
Seniority mix The balance you expect, without naming individuals “Mostly senior engineers, with one lead”
Named people Whether bidders should name the people who will work on it “Name the lead and say how the rest of the team is assigned”
Substitution What happens if someone leaves “Tell us your replacement process and notice period”

5. Technical environment

Field What to write Example
Python and frameworks Version and main frameworks in use “A current Python 3 release; Django for the web layer; FastAPI for internal services”
Data stack Databases and data stores the tests must touch “PostgreSQL for transactional data; a message queue for async jobs”
Cloud and infrastructure Where the application runs “Containerised services on a managed cloud platform”
Repositories and CI Where code lives and how it is built “Monorepo on a hosted Git service; CI runs lint and unit tests on every pull request”
Test tooling Tools you already use or want “pytest for unit and API tests; a browser automation tool for end-to-end”

6. Working practices

Field What to write Example
Time-zone overlap Minimum shared hours per working day “At least four hours overlapping with our core hours”
Sprint cadence How work is planned and reviewed “Two-week sprints with a demo at the end of each”
Reporting What you want to see and how often “A weekly written status note and a defect summary per sprint”
Communication Channels and meeting rhythm “Shared chat channel; one stand-up per day”

7. Security, IP and compliance

Field What to write Example
Data access What test data and environments bidders will see “Anonymised staging data only; no production access”
Security requirements Standards or checks you require “Background checks for staff with repository access; secrets kept in a managed vault”
IP ownership Who owns the test code and documentation “All test code and documentation owned by us on delivery”
Compliance Any regulatory constraints on the work “State any relevant certifications your team holds”

8. Commercial terms

Field What to write Example
Pricing model How you want the bid priced “Monthly rate per role, plus a separate line for any fixed-scope phase”
Budget range Your range, or a statement that none is set “[Buyer fills in]”
Payment terms When invoices are due “Monthly invoicing, payable within the period stated in our standard terms”
Notice period How either side can end the engagement “One month’s written notice on either side”
Expenses What is included in the rate “All tooling and travel included; no separate expenses”

9. Selection process and timeline

Field What to write Example
Deadline When written replies are due “Replies by the date stated in the covering email”
Evaluation steps What happens after the written reply “Written review, then a short call with the proposed lead”
Decision date When you expect to choose “A decision within two weeks of the calls”
Feedback Whether unsuccessful bidders hear from you “A short written note to every bidder”

10. Questions every bidder must answer

Field What to write Example
Relevant testing work Ask for comparable QA engagements, described in the bidder’s own words “Describe two Python test automation projects and your role in each”
Approach to this scope Ask how they would start and what they would test first “Outline your first month, including which tests you would automate first”
Risks Ask what could go wrong and how they would handle it “Name the main risks you see in our environment and your mitigation”
Assumptions Ask them to state every assumption behind the price “List the assumptions your quote depends on”
References Ask for contacts you may speak to “Two client references for similar testing work”

Comparing the replies

Copy this table once per bidder and fill in the weight column before you read any reply, so the weighting is fixed in advance. The criteria are yours to change; the point is that every bidder is scored on the same list.

Criterion Weight (buyer sets) What to look for in the reply Score (buyer sets)
Relevant Python testing evidence Comparable automation, API or performance work, described concretely
Understanding of the scope First-month plan that matches your goals and environment
Team fit Named lead, seniority mix, overlap with your hours
Working practices Reporting, sprint rhythm and communication that suit your team
Security and IP Clear answers on data access, checks and ownership of test code
Commercial clarity Pricing model stated plainly, assumptions listed, no hidden lines
Risks and assumptions Honest about what could go wrong rather than promising everything
References Contacts you can actually reach

Common mistakes in briefs

Mistake Consequence Fix
Describing the goal in one line Each bidder prices a different project Write success criteria as observable outcomes
Leaving the engagement model open Some bids are per person, others per project, and cannot be compared State a preferred model and say whether alternatives are welcome
Hiding the budget range Bids arrive at wildly different scopes Give a range, or say explicitly that none is set
Sending different versions to different bidders Answers no longer line up Use one document and one deadline for all
Answering one bidder’s question privately That bidder has information the others lack Send the question and your answer to everyone
Skipping the assumptions question Prices look comparable but rest on different premises Require a written list of assumptions with every bid

Frequently asked questions

How many companies should receive the brief?

Three to five is a workable number: enough to see different approaches, few enough that you can score every reply properly. Sending it to more usually means shallower evaluation rather than a better decision.

What if a bidder proposes a different engagement model?

Allow it, but ask that bidder to also price the model you asked for, so the two can sit side by side in your scoring table. A different model is often a useful signal about how the company works.

Should the brief include our budget?

Yes, if you have a range. Bidders who know the range can propose a scope that fits it instead of guessing. If no range exists, say so in the field rather than leaving it blank, so nobody assumes a figure.

Can we reuse this template for later projects?

Yes. Keep the section order and the questions every bidder must answer, and update the context, scope and environment sections each time. A consistent structure also lets you compare a new bid with replies you kept from an earlier round.

Get a shortlist

Python QA Testing Companies